Until two years ago the Montreat Church had never elected a woman as elder. We knew we were a dinosaur, but we didn’t feel the need to be fashionably up to date. It wasn’t that we barred women from ordination to office; in fact, women in our church had been ordained to the office of deacon for years.
Although some people were in favor of women elders, and others thought Scripture specifically forbade seating women on the session, we thrived as a church. We lived together with the understanding that if a woman were elected, she would be ordained and installed. But we made no formal effort to wrestle with the issue of women elders. Then one day our presbytery executive called. I’ll never forget his greeting: “Hello, Richard. We’ve got a problem.”
Our problem became apparent when one Sunday a pastor in our presbytery used the Montreat Church in a sermon illustration, noting that we were one of the few PCUSA churches that did not have women elders. “We’ve got a problem” came the next morning.
The presbytery executive asked to speak with our session about our church’s lack of compliance with the Book of Order. At our meeting we discussed options and asked the scary “what if” questions.
Our questions centered on the seeming contradiction in the Book of Order which says, “every congregation shall elect men and women…to the office of elder,” but which also says, “The right of God’s people to elect their officers is inalienable” (G-14.0201 and G-6.0107, respectively). One elder asked bluntly, “Why can’t there be a church in this denomination that doesn’t have women elders?”
Our executive had two things to say. “We have decided.” And, “This is who we are.”
As a result of that meeting our session developed an action plan which was intended to educate our congregation and remove any barriers that we had inadvertently placed in the way of women’s ordination. The presbytery’s Committee on Ministry encouraged us by enthusiastically receiving our plan. We chugged ahead in the months that followed, distributing materials, pro and con, on the subject of women as elders. We organized a debate. Parker Williamson argued for women’s ordination while a seminary professor of the Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church argued against it. In many additional meetings the congregation asked questions of session members. Finally, we gave especially careful instruction on the whole issue of women’s ordination to the nominating committee. We studied the Scriptures and the Book of Order in much depth.
When the seven-month study time was over, we were all somewhat shocked when a woman was actually elected to the session. We thought it would take years if it happened at all. But Garlene jumped right in and started fulfilling her calling in a wonderful way. The congregation reaffirmed her ministry and leadership a year later by electing her to a full three-year term, since she had been originally elected to fill a one-year unexpired term. We are now a more effective session because of Garlene’s presence. So, in regard to women elders, the Montreat Church is not looking back.
And yet, in fairness to my brothers and sisters in the Montreat Church, I must not paint a simple picture of clear blue skies and bright sunshine. This has been an incredibly painful time for our church. Scattered clouds of mistrust and broken relationships hover in the atmosphere. Several families (on both sides of the issue) left the church. A few vocal opponents of women in leadership claimed the election had been rigged. One woman, the wife of an elder who took a public stand for women’s ordination, had a nervous breakdown.
When I mentioned these things to the Committee on Ministry, folks spoke pastorally. However, they also stated matter-of-factly that these things may have to happen in order for us to be the Presbyterian Church we say we are.
Indeed, even people who welcome the ministry of women elders are not grateful for the process that was single-minded in its purpose for the Montreat Church to be a PCUSA church just like all the rest. I still hear, even two years later, that the presbytery “put a gun to our head.” What if our church had not complied and elected a woman at the first opportunity? Our presbytery executive made it clear that we could be disciplined. The presbytery could have cleared the session and seated the elders of their choice. That’s pretty strong medicine for a problem that many people think was slowly working itself out.
As I try to assess all that took place I make the following observations:
As a denomination, we can take a definitive stand on an issue. We have eliminated women’s ordination as a matter of debate. Even if it brings tears and loss of members, even if gifted people we love end up having to leave the church, we understand that and are willing to abide by that. For Christ’s sake, let us now as a denomination go on to take a definitive stand on the issues that are the most central to the peace, purity and unity of the Church.
Some people have asked if the presbytery exercised redemptive or vindictive discipline. Frankly, we received a mixed message. Nevertheless, I am grateful for the patience of the presbytery in allowing our local session to deal with the issue in a manner suitable to our congregation. One woman elder on the Committee on Ministry urged the other members to be patient with the Montreat Church, to let the study take place and to realize that it may be years before a woman would be elected. If there was a proverbial gun to our head, at least no one was trigger happy.
I observe that church membership is like a marriage. We bind ourselves to each other within certain boundaries. We agree to hold each other accountable in order to preserve our union. Although it was not easy, the elders of the Montreat Church worked hard with our presbytery to abide by the discipline of the PCUSA. We fulfilled our vows and have welcomed women into the ministry.
When I reflect on how we endured this discipline, I wonder where the disciplinarians have gone. Ministers and churches in our denomination willfully disregard the ordination standards “we have decided” as a denomination. Conferences offer keynote addresses which contradict Scripture and our confessions—those documents that say “who we are.” Under the guise of opinion, error is espoused as truth. When the “issue” of the singular saving work of Jesus Christ comes under attack, egregious actions and declarations go unchecked by the presbyteries and agencies charged with coordination and review. Apparently it’s not the kind of issue they can address. But the makeup of the sessions of churches with memberships under 350 is. When we see and experience that, honestly, it’s a struggle to maintain confidence in the integrity and ability of those agencies to justly lead and direct us in the way and truth of Jesus Christ.
Discipline is a necessary part of the church’s life, for which we are grateful. However, when the discipline is mainly attentive to process but careless with essentials, we can only say, “Hello, we have a problem.”
This article first appeared in Theology Matters, Vol. 8, No. 4 (Jul/Aug 2002).






