Opens in a new tab
Church Renewal, Church Unity & Ecumenism, Essay, PCUSA

Reform From Within

Should faithful Presbyterians stay and work for reform, or leave? Terry Schlossberg turns to Wilberforce, the prophets and the Reformers to argue that repentance, discipline and patient work from within are the way forward.

Listen to this essay
 

Read by an AI voice generated by ElevenLabs

A portrait of William Wilberforce, the English reformer
A portrait from the Welsh Portrait Collection at the National Library of Wales. Joseph John Jenkins, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
In this essay

Reprinted with permission from the plenary presentation at Coalition Gathering VIII, Portland, OR, October, 2003.

Every one of us, I suspect, understands the emotions that underlie a desire to break with the troubles of this denomination and seek to establish something better and more faithful to our Lord. We all understand the desire to concentrate fully on our call to mission and evangelism; to the proper and faithful proclamation of the Gospel and the building up of the body that initially brought our pastors into ministry and our members to join our churches. We understand the fatigue over battles fought and refought. We understand the discouragement over problems too numerous and too big. We understand the desire to concentrate on what seems to come more naturally to our calling and that feels more rewarding. We understand not wanting to fight political battles and not even feeling equipped for it or good at it. There probably is not one of us who hasn’t asked, “What am I doing here in the midst of a battle over orthodoxy?”

But, we are not the first to face serious troubles in the Church of Jesus Christ. And just like those who have fought similar battles before our time, we know the unpleasant reality of how easily human beings and institutions fall into sin and decay. And we know, too, that the way to restoration is often long and difficult and unpleasant.

We really do seem to be in one of those critical historical moments in the Christian Church. We are not simply looking for new ways of doing church, as some express it—for ways to adapt age-old truths to a new generation in order to make the truth relevant in our own time. Rather, what makes our situation exceptional, if it is, is that we are up against aggressive forces that wish to so change Christian Faith that what would be passed down to future generations would be very different from what we have received.

Some of us are wondering whether we ought to spend our energies to preserve an institution—a denomination—a particular expression of the visible church. When we talk about this, though, we need to separate discussion of what we think may be outmoded forms from discussion of corruption in the current forms. We in the Reform From Within work group are focused on the latter—on ways in which the intent of our community life as a denomination has been corrupted so much that orthodoxy itself is threatened.

Loving What We Seek To Change

We Presbyterians may claim adoption into both the invisible and the visible body of Christ. As a part of the visible body we need to consider our Lord’s demands of love on us. One of Charles Schultz’s posters has Snoopy declaring “I love mankind. It’s people I can’t stand.” Many of us have a deep love for the Presbyterian Church—for its roots and its history and its ministry in our personal lives. But we are shocked and disgusted by its current condition, even to the point of wanting to part company with people in it (cf Haggai 2).

Maybe we have a Jonah syndrome. He ran because he really didn’t want to see repentance come to Nineveh. And when his ministry was successful he went off and pouted. A note in my Bible says “The magnanimous heart of God, forgiving the repentant heathen, appears in strong contrast to the narrow, bigoted and unforgiving spirit of Jonah.” At the end of the book God expresses his pity for Nineveh “the whole city” because, he says, in it “are twenty thousand persons who do not know their right hand from their left….” We ought to consider the extent of our pity for those in our “city” who do not know their right hand from their left.

King Solomon’s prayer for God’s people in 2 Chronicles anticipates their future rebellion against God. Solomon prays for them, that God will hear their prayers of repentance and forgive and restore them. It’s a prayer that expresses a leader’s deep love for an errant people, a desire for their restoration, and confidence in the power and the will of God to restore them. That body of people, like every form of the visible church, was an institution. The visible church doesn’t exist without institutional form and the institution has never existed without need for reform. In some periods, and I think this is one, the need for reforms reaches a critical level.

Are We Going Backward Or Forward?

We face difficulties that our predecessors in similar exceptional times also faced. We can analyze our problems fairly well. But what we cannot do well is judge our progress. I have a couple of favorite examples of this difficulty. One is William Wilberforce, a central figure in the reform of English society in the 19th century. Wilberforce professed to have two calls from God: to end slavery in England and to improve the morals of his country. He spent 40 years working to accomplish an end to slavery. But at the end of his life, Wilberforce thought there had been no improvement in the morals of his countrymen; that, in fact, conditions were worse than ever. But historical study shows a marked transformation during his lifetime in nearly every area of English society. Such things as public drunkenness, crime, child labor, illiteracy, general immorality, church attendance, conversions to faith in Jesus Christ and overall order in the society all improved significantly and much of it as a direct result of his own work. He was just too close to it to see it.

The second example comes from a conference on the persecuted Church that was held in 1990. Jane Ellis, now deceased, was a scholar and expert on the church under communism. She was asked by one of the conference participants if she saw any hope for change ahead for the churches in communist-dominated countries. Her reply was that unfortunately she saw absolutely no prospects for change. Only months later to her complete surprise—along with the rest of the world’s—the Berlin wall fell.

These accounts illustrate that human beings do much better at reading the signs of the times in retrospect; we’re better historians than prophets. They also illustrate that long periods of very bad conditions can change suddenly: what is, is not necessarily what has to be or what is going to be. We often are not cognizant of all the forces at work influencing outcomes. Just by selection of events, we may perceive that our situation is improving or deteriorating.

Understanding Our Calling

So, how shall we understand our calling in these times, in this denomination? First, it’s important for us to realize that the difficulties we face permeate our whole culture today. Every institution of our society is facing similar efforts at deChristianization. And every mainline denomination is dealing with efforts to redefine the faith and practice of Christianity. I read again recently that the next major field of conquest targeted by the religious homosexual lobby is the non-mainline evangelical denominations. When we have this discussion of our problems and our response, we are not discussing an isolated situation. We are discussing a period in history, a situation common to our whole culture, and a challenge to the whole of the Christian Church.

We are called to this conflict in this church. It is necessary for us to comprehend the nature of the conflict in our own church so that we can work on becoming as wise as serpents and innocent as doves as we seek the reformation of our own body. We need to give ourselves to the restoration of righteousness right where we are and thereby hold up hope that we are contributing to the restoration and not to the demise of the whole church. We need to care about the people both inside and outside the church who are so vulnerable to being led away from that “faith once delivered.”

It is difficult not to see our situation in the PCUSA as rather dire, but we must be careful not to think of ourselves as two churches. We are one church under one constitution. Some of us wish to see that constitution upheld and others wish not only to change it but to reverse it, and some by any means possible. We are not two parties of equal standing who cannot agree. Rather, some among us mean to be true to revelation and to the ordination vows we have taken and others are willing to break those vows and reconstruct the truth to conform to a human agenda.

We are in a situation that calls for the exercise of church discipline. We who are committed to the work of renewal are charged by some with lack of progress in reforms and lack of a will to discipline, and the charges have validity. But we should not think that those in previous reform efforts had stronger wills or made faster progress. And we should not kid ourselves into thinking that we can go somewhere else and not find our own weaknesses facing us squarely wherever we go. Separation is a course that admits defeat and yields to the temptation to believe that God is not with us. It calls us to act in response to our weakness, to the length of the struggle, to our fatigue and sense of futility, rather than to declare our weakness and call out to God for help.

Help From The Bible

The truest analogies for our situation are found in the New Testament letters to the churches. Those letters are replete with every problem we face in our denomination, and more: Galatians with its other Gospel; Corinthians with its sexual immorality are examples. Those letters show how many disagreements and problems of polity, morality and doctrine early church leaders addressed. Let us recall, too, the early chapters of Revelation and what the Spirit said to the churches. Let us read them and weep over the state of the New Testament church. The situations were surely as troubled as our own. And the response was a constant call to repentance, to reform and to correction; never to passive acceptance or to abandonment.

The Old Testament, too, is full of the prophets’ listings of the evils committed by those God elected as his own beloved people, along with the repeated calls for repentance and the constant promises of restoration. Recall Ezekiel sent as a watchman to a people who would not listen and would not repent. Recall Jeremiah and Micaiah, imprisoned for repeating God’s words to Israel’s leaders. Recall King Jehoiakim defiantly slicing and burning the words dictated by God to Jeremiah. Yet these prophets, even reluctantly, sought no escape. They continued faithfully to deliver God’s revelation and stayed with the people, even into exile.

Those are the models for dealing with apostasy, heresy, and even structural power plays in the church from the very beginning; in times, like our own, of intense controversy in the Church. And those are the models that the Reformers followed. They didn’t leave the church voluntarily. They were forced out by a price put on their heads.

The Picture Is Not Completely Black

So, let’s take a realistic look at our own situation. We must be careful not to overstate the negatives. It would be good for us even briefly to rehearse some of the positives. For example,

  • Consider: that we have faced and met the challenge to the biblical understanding of sexuality for more than a quarter of a century. While officers and members are engaged in sinful sexual behaviors in numbers much larger than we even want to think about, our standards remain biblically faithful.
  • Consider: that we have faced and met the challenge of ReImagining and other similar theological heresies regarding the Trinity and our Savior. Constitutionally, we hold an orthodox theology, in spite of the active pressure for what my husband calls “crooked-doxy” in various quarters of the denomination. If the affirmations by General Assemblies have not been as strong as we would like, neither have they been the repudiations that those promoting the heresies wanted.
  • Consider: that we have not gone further backward morally on the issues of the meaning and value of human life since the disastrous abortion policy of 1983 and, in fact, have made advances both on issues at the beginning and the end of life. There has been no capitulation to the abortion rights position even though some public figures have declared again and again over the years that this issue has been settled.
  • Consider: that, after decades of ignoring Scripture, the confessions and catechisms, there is a rather pronounced return of attention to all three, and a kindling of interest in doctrine at virtually every level of our denomination.
  • Consider: that, despite efforts to redefine terms and finance a one-sided “justice” agenda as a substitute for evangelism and mission, nevertheless evangelism and mission continue to be matters of high priority for Presbyterians and efforts in both these areas meet with great support and enthusiasm as evidenced by the growing work of the validated mission organizations and the success of efforts like Knox Fellowship.

Signs of Progress Against Formidable Odds

In their upbeat Christianity Today article (August 2003), Hamilton and McKinney tell readers about recent successes of renewal efforts in the mainline denominations and opine that “new sociological studies show that evangelicals may well succeed at renewing wayward Protestantism.” The writers hold out hope for success based on the active ferment at the grass roots of our denominations; in our congregations where orthodoxy thrives. In an even more recent article, CT discusses the developing strategies of renewalists that are having increasing impact on the governing bodies of all the mainline denominations.

Renewal efforts in our denomination are not ancient. They are relatively new. When I began my work in the PCUSA less than two decades ago, we faced an entrenched bureaucracy that had an intractable grip on our denomination with a number of leaders who radically opposed orthodoxy. The opposition is still there in many quarters, but the grip no longer exists, and we have seen many positive developments. We have had to go through a process of making lots of mistakes as we learn how to be effective disciples not only in mission but also in the political process. And we are still learning.

However, the challenges before us are formidable. But, instead of a view of our situation that emphasizes the length of the struggle or the strength and entrenchment of opposing forces, we ought to see that we are in one of those important historical moments when what we chose to do; the stand we take and the witness we give—will affect the future of the Church for a very long time.

It is repentance and restoration—not separation—that are needed. We have taken vows ourselves. We are the Church Militant, as the confessions describe us; at war with the spirit of the age and with our own besetting sins. The road to recovery of the faithful church is marked first by repentance; the confession of our sin and the simple decision to stop doing what is wrong and start doing what is right. John Calvin says in the Institutes that repentance is our first calling and it is a calling to the end of our days.

And secondly, the road to recovery is marked by the exercise of church discipline. I suspect that we ourselves have been more than a little deficient in both these areas. And separation will not substitute for either one.

The Way Forward

On the matter of a way forward, as on many other things, we will not have complete agreement. On some matters we have significant differences. But John Calvin says in The Necessity of Reforming the Church that the Reformers sought only to improve the condition of the church a little. He was no utopian. However, to give leadership, we need to come to agreement and a plan of action on our priorities.

Scripture emphasizes the importance of both congregational life and a structure that provides for unity among the congregations. In the New Testament church, there was both the establishing of ministers, elders and deacons in the churches, and the sort of oversight and communication among the churches provided for by the apostles. The Reformation retained the need for a unified theology and polity.

As problematic as our current structure in practice appears to be, we will have to move toward reforms that restore the proper role of the higher governing bodies of the Church in order to avoid becoming congregational.

The most important reforms we need are those that transform life in our local governing bodies, in our congregations and presbyteries. Without changes there, the efforts for change at the higher levels of the church can be counterproductive. For example, changes in the process of the General Assembly Nominating Committee at the top will be of little effect if we do not have godly leadership equipped and ready to put forward from our sessions and presbyteries.

We also must exercise with much greater care the responsibility of our sessions and our presbyteries to examine candidates for elder and minister. We need to ensure that those we ordain and install into ministry meet the theological standards of orthodoxy.

We should be looking for reforms that have potential for the greatest impact for the amount of energy and resources expended. We should be looking for reforms that have the largest ripple effect.

Here are four that meet these criteria:

  1. Restore proper representation to presbyteries and General Assembly.
  2. Reform the nominating and election process so that elections at all levels of the church are moved as far down in the governing bodies as possible and there is full disclosure of candidates in term of fitness for service, commitment to the constitution, and experience suitable to the office or committee.
  3. Press for a Stated Clerk committed to and willing to use his/her influence to see that the constitution is upheld and obeyed.
  4. Concentrate effort to carefully, strategically, and consistently exercise church discipline, particularly in cases of refusal to obey the constitution.

A decision for reform will require the commitment and support of each one of us. It will require serious focus on identifying the priorities for action that we will press for in the next few years. It will require the development of a strategy, financial support, recruitment, and preparation of those to do the work; encouragement and activation of our churches in the effort; and perseverance and patience for God’s timing.

Conclusion

We face nothing new in this current struggle and we dare not regard it as if God were absent and not at work among us. We ourselves are being tested by these current troubles. Our situation calls for patience and a willingness to try and fail, never losing faith that God intends ultimately to bless and care for his church and will not abandon her or us, but rather, will bless and nurture us and bring all this trouble to the best possible outcome. These are times that challenge our determination to reclaim the church for orthodoxy. Let us, then, declare, as David did when he faced Goliath, “You come to me with a sword and with a spear and with a javelin; but I come to you in the name of the Lord of hosts, the God of the armies of Israel, whom you have defied…that all the earth may know that there is a God in Israel and that all this assembly may know that the Lord saves not with sword and spear; for the battle is the Lord’s and he will give you into our hand” (1 Samuel 17:44-47).

We, like William Wilberforce, may wonder if our efforts are having any effect while God is carrying out his will in and through us. We should learn from Wilberforce’s foolish misreading of his time in history not to judge our own prematurely. We should allow his error to chasten our own lack of faith in God whom we know is working everything for his own good purposes. That is not being a Pollyanna; that is expressing the hope we are called to have because of the promises we have from the God who governs the whole thing, and who declares that nothing is too hard for him!

This address first appeared in Theology Matters, Vol. 10, No. 1 (Jan/Feb 2004).

Continue the issue

Continue Reading

More Articles

View All Articles
Reader-Supported

"Sustained by readers."

Theology Matters is sent in print to anyone who requests it, sustained primarily by readers like you. Tax-deductible.

Give a Gift