Baptism, Church Unity & Ecumenism, Creeds, Essay

A Conversation with the Ecumenical Creeds

Why do so many Christians treat the old creeds as out of date? Leanne Van Dyk sets out seven things the Apostles’ and Nicene Creeds do for a church, from identifying believers at baptism and teaching the faith to uniting Christians and comforting the broken.

Listen to this essay
 

Read by an AI voice generated by ElevenLabs

Orthodox icon of the bishops at the First Council of Nicaea
Unknown authorUnknown author, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
In this essay

Adapted with permission from “A Conversation with the Ecumenical Creeds” in Conversation with the Confessions, ed. Joseph Small (Louisville: Geneva Press, 2005), pp 17-31. The entire article is on our website. Used by permission of Presbyterian Publishing Corporation www.ppcbooks.com.

Strangely, when we approach the New Testament, we instinctively think that old is good, but when it comes to creeds and confessions we tend to assume that old is bad. We respect the fact that the Gospel of Mark is old, probably older than the other Gospels. In certain circles, Mark (and perhaps the enigmatic Q) have an extra quota of authenticity due to their age. The older Letter to the Galatians seems to carry more authority with some people than the later epistles to Timothy and Titus. But the Apostles’ Creed and the Nicene Creed are routinely dismissed by some because they are so old. How can such old documents, so the argument goes, have anything to say to us in our contemporary setting? For these people, A Brief Statement of Faith and the Confession of 1967 seem much more relevant.

Kathleen Norris tells the story of a seminary student and an Orthodox priest-theologian at Yale Divinity School. It is a story that has been quoted widely because it so perfectly captures the contemporary suspicion of creeds. The theologian had come as a guest speaker to lecture on the history of the creeds in the Christian tradition. In a time for questions after the lecture, a student asked, “What can one do when one finds it impossible to affirm certain tenets of the Creed?” The priest answered by saying, “Well, you just say it. With a little practice and effort, most can learn it by heart.”

The student apparently felt misunderstood and so asked a follow-up question: “What am I to do if I find I cannot affirm parts of the Creed, like the Virgin Birth?” The answer was the same, “You just stand with the congregation and say it. You keep saying it. Eventually it will come to you, with practice and time.” Once more the student, this time in a raised voice, said, “How can I say a creed that I do not believe?” Then the priest said, “It is not your creed, it is our creed. It may come to you, in time. For some, it takes longer than for others.”1

The frustrated student was voicing an assumption that many in the church have—that ancient creeds are subject to individual scrutiny. If one agrees with them, fine. If one does not, then the creeds may be, perhaps even must be, discarded. The Orthodox theologian was operating with an entirely different assumption—that the ancient creeds are the treasurers of the whole church that shape and form us slowly over time. We place ourselves under their tutelage, in trust and confidence, because they have been the patient teachers of countless believers, who have gone before us. Now we too are in the procession of believers who stand after the proclamation of the Word and confess in one voice what we believe. Kathleen Norris’s story is illuminating because we can place our own attitudes toward the ancient creeds with either the student or the priest—or perhaps we find sympathy with both.

We find sympathy with the student in the story, because, deep in our bones, we are children of the Enlightenment. We have all grown up assuming that we are the arbiters of our own destiny, that each of us individually decides what to buy, whom to marry, what our political convictions are, and what we believe. Yet we sympathize with the priest in the story because, deep in our hearts, we are lonely and anxious. We have discovered that the ideal of the “lone individual” of our culture is frequently isolating and dividing. On the one hand, we resist the notion of standing together with the generations of believers who have come before us to confess the great creeds of faith—we want to choose! On the other hand, we long to join our voice with the great chorus of voices proclaiming a common faith—we want to belong!

In our consideration of the Apostles’ and the Nicene Creeds, then, it is helpful to realize the ambiguity that many contemporary people sense when they rise to profess their faith in the words of one of these great ecumenical creeds. The uneasiness they may feel is seldom analyzed, of course. Few people say, “I am the heir of a confused Enlightenment inheritance. I long both for autonomy and connection. The words of the creeds raise this ambiguity in my mind.”

Other cultural factors conspire against glad acceptance of the ancient creeds as well. The dominant cultural attitudes of the West are strikingly individualistic and autonomous. Although Asian and African cultures are more sensitive to family and community contexts, even these traditional cultures are being pressured by the segmenting forces of global economies and cultural influences from the West.

In this dominant global cultural model, each person is the sole arbiter of his or her own set of beliefs, opinions, and decisions. There are multiple ironies in this dominant cultural model, however. In spite of the claims of individual autonomy and freedom, it is no secret that adolescents are loathe to stand out from their peers and will carefully moderate their behavior to fit in with the crowd. This behavior does not disappear even among mature adults. The pressures of the group are powerful factors in consumer habits, a fact that advertisers are quick to exploit in their advertising campaigns. In spite of the fact that we like to think we make up our own minds about everything, our behavior in the marketplace, at least, betrays the deeper truth that we move with the crowd and have a profound need to fit in.

The pervasive antiauthoritarianism of contemporary culture also impacts attitudes toward worship and creeds. In a May 23, 2004, Los Angeles Times article, “Religion: the Do-It-Yourself Doctrine,” journalist Charlotte Allen notes that a common attitude among contemporary Christians is that no one should tell anyone how to practice his or her faith, or even what the faith is. Interestingly, this attitude characterizes both progressive and evangelical sectors of the denominational spectrum. Allen notes that along with this attitude is an additional assumption that the ancient creeds crushed vibrant and diverse spiritualities in the early Christian communities, that they destroyed a flourishing of lively faith. What is common to these contemporary marks of American religion is a deep assumption that each person has an indubitable right to craft a tailor-made relationship with their own faith.

The ecumenical creeds do not fare well in this cultural climate. It is not difficult to see that when it comes to creeds and confessions, we tend to assume that old is bad. Some Christian observers, however, believe that the creeds are not a “take’em or leave’em” proposition. New Testament scholar Luke Timothy Johnson puts in a good word for the ancient creeds, pointing out that they did not oppressively crush other flourishing spiritualities. Rather, they grew up in very early Christian communities as a way of defining who the people of faith were so that it could become clear what it meant to live by the faith. Johnson comments in Allen’s article, “But nowadays it’s amazing how many people believe that the creeds were foisted on Christianity. There’s this belief that structure and spontaneity are opposites, and that traditional Christianity is incompatible with mysticism and with communal and egalitarian experience. That’s never been true. It’s a sociological fantasy of the 1960s.” Johnson would not deny that politics played a part in the formation of the creeds, especially the Nicene Creed and, later still, the fifth century Chalcedonian Definition. But the basic impulse to formulate creeds is not to dominate and oppress; rather, it is to express a fundamental identity in Christian faith. That identity sometimes came in the midst of persecution and opposition, a reality some Christian communities still experience in the world today.

The Function of Creeds

Because reciting a creed creates ambiguities for contemporary believers, it might be helpful to remind ourselves how creeds function and what their potential is for strengthening and nurturing Christian faith.2 First of all, creeds identify Christian believers in the faith. This is exactly how the Apostles’ Creed was used in the early history of the church. The roots of the Apostles’ Creed go back deep into the early church, to the instruction of converts into the Christian faith.3 After a period of instruction in the faith, often lasting for weeks or months, converts were ready for the sacrament of baptism. In the early church, baptism was the ceremony of drama and symbolism, highlighting the great change of identity that was about to happen to the convert, to be joined with the body of Christ and the community of believers. Each convert was asked a series of questions by the minister or priest. In an important third-century document, the church father Hippolytus records detailed instructions for baptism using an early form of the Apostles’ Creed. Here we can see how the creed is used as a tool for shaping basic Christian identity.

And [when] he [who is to be baptized] goes down to the water, let him who baptizes lay [his] hand on him saying thus:

Dost thou believe in God the Father Almighty?
And he who is being baptized shall say: I believe.
Let him forthwith baptize him once, having his hand laid upon his head.
And after this let him say:
Dost thou believe in Christ Jesus, the Son of God, Who was born of the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary,
Who was crucified in the days of Pontius Pilate, and died,
And rose on the third day living from the dead
And ascended into the heavens,
And sat down at the right hand of the Father,
And will come again to judge the living and the dead?
And when he says: I believe, let him baptize him the second time.
And again let him say:
Dost thou believe in the Holy Spirit in the Holy Church, and the resurrection of the flesh?
And he who is being baptized shall say: I believe.
And so let him baptize him the third time.4

Second, the ecumenical creeds educate persons in their Christian beliefs. One of my professors once commented that young Christian minds do not naturally come fully furnished with the content of the faith. Teachers are needed to bring in the “furniture”—the tables, sofas, and carpets of the major doctrines. That is why the Trinity, Jesus Christ, and the Holy Spirit are included in the Apostles’ Creed and the Nicene Creed, but precise lists of divine attributes are not. Smaller “decorative objects,” say, the curtains and the candlesticks of the room, the theory of divine inspiration and the doctrine of the intermediate state, can come at a later time. But the creeds furnish the minds of new Christians with the basic furniture of faith.

This is why John Calvin insisted that the people in his congregation in Geneva memorize the Apostles’ Creed. Most people in that city of refugees were illiterate tradespeople and merchants who had never received an education. Neither had they ever learned, in their spoken language, the Lord’s Prayer and the Apostles’ Creed. One of the reforms that Calvin brought to Geneva was worship services in the French language, the language of most of the people in the city. Calvin required that church members memorize the Lord’s Prayer and the Apostles’ Creed as a basic minimum of literacy in the faith. The creed functioned as a tool of education.

Third, the ecumenical creeds unify Christian believers. This can be seen most simply by the very first word of the Nicene Creed: the word “We.” The purpose of the Nicene Creed was to unify a painfully divided Christian community over a dispute that had been brewing between two factions in the church. These factions had all the markings of political parties, with political maneuverings, followers, gifted speakers, smear campaigns, and genuine issues of importance.

The details of this doctrinal skirmish were complex and philosophically freighted, but the fundamental issue went to the very heart of the Christian gospel: Who is Jesus Christ? This basic question was then, and still is, of fundamental importance to Christians. Simply stated, the matter before the bishops of Nicea had to do with the identity of Jesus Christ. Is Jesus Christ truly God? Or is Jesus Christ a “junior-level deity”?

The Council of Nicea concluded with a vigorous affirmation of Jesus Christ’s full divinity, of the fully divine nature of the incarnate Christ. The creed of Nicea, then, was formulated to state the faith of the whole church, the faith of what “we” believe. Yes, it was written by bishops, the teachers of the church, based on existing regional creeds already in use. But this creed, more than any other, has been received by the many diverse Christian traditions. Millions of Christian people stand each Sunday after the proclamation of the Word to say “We believe” in the affirmations of the Nicene Creed. This has been occurring for over fifteen hundred years in countless languages on every continent. When we express our faith in the words of the Nicene Creed, we stand with the “cloud of witnesses” that goes before us in the faith that unites us.

The capacity of creeds to unite believers is not limited to ancient creeds. The catechisms and confessions of the Reformation were also written in times of controversy and danger, and functioned to draw people together. The best contemporary example of the unifying role of creeds is the 1934 Barmen Declaration, now one of the confessional documents of the PC(USA). In the 1930s, the witness of the Christian church in Germany was co-opted by the official ideology of the Nazi regime. Pastors were required to pledge their allegiance to Adolf Hitler; swastika flags were hung in church sanctuaries, and pastors who spoke out in protest against the increasing Nazi control over both church and society were removed from their posts. A small resistance movement of Lutheran, Reformed, and United Church pastors organized the “Confessional Synod” of the German Evangelical Church to oppose the “German Christian” accommodation to National Socialism. A representative group of pastors drafted the Barmen Declaration as an appeal to the church to proclaim the lordship of Jesus Christ and resist the state’s pretentions to lordship. In a context of threat to the integrity of the gospel and danger to the church, the Theological Declaration of Barmen brought the Confessing Church together, gave it an identity, and clarified its Christian call in that particular time and place.

Fourth, creeds have an apologetic and polemical function. This is perhaps the most difficult function for us to accept in a cultural context that is multiethnic, multicultural, and multireligious. We live in a society that requires of us tolerance and acceptance for peoples of other cultures and other faiths.

Nevertheless, when Christians state what they believe, they also mark off what they do not believe. When we say the familiar words of the Apostles’ Creed, for example, we are clearly indicating many alternatives that we do not affirm. Imagine saying the Apostles’ Creed, declaring what you do believe and then silently declaring what you are rejecting. In our contemporary context, the primary affirmations of the Apostles’ Creed might come with these accompanying rejections.6

I believe in God, the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth. (not in the stock market or military might)

And in Jesus Christ, his only Son our Lord (not in the many false lordships of the world that tempt me to turn away from Jesus Christ or that offer themselves as alternatives to Christ)

I believe in the Holy Ghost (Not in my spirit as the final measure of reality).

In a religiously diverse culture, we sometimes get the mistaken impression that we must not reject anything, that it is somehow impolite to state clearly what we believe and, likewise, what we do not believe. But this is not the case. As our communities and neighborhoods become ever more diverse and multicultural, it is even more important to find clarity and identity in our baptism and in the creed that was spoken at our baptism.

Fifth, creeds have a doxological function. They are one of the ways we praise God, because the words of the creed give voice to our faith and trust in the one triune God whom we worship and glorify. This creedal way of praising God has long been practiced by the church as it has used the Apostles’ Creed in celebrations of baptism and the Nicene Creed in the Eucharistic liturgy. When we think of the creeds as a gift of praise to God, as an offering of the best words the Christian tradition has produced to express its faith, the creeds can become a doxology rather than an act of rote memorization.

Sixth, the creeds edify Christians. The first meaning of the word “edify” in the dictionary is to “instruct,” but this is not the meaning I have in mind. The second dictionary meaning of “edify” is to “enlighten.” This points to the “aha” moments that sometimes occur when a new insight flashes or a fresh perspective dawns—or what happens, every once in a while, when a Christian believer recites the Apostles’ Creed or the Nicene Creed. It may not happen often. But the creeds can edify; they can enlighten. So it pays to be alert. It even pays to study the creeds, to learn their unique language, their history, the issues at stake in their writing, for a fresh insight or new perspective may emerge from this process of study.

Consider an example. One particularly lovely line in the Nicene Creed is the first line about the Holy Spirit. “We believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord and giver of life.” This is a line that can be repeated dozens, hundreds of times, perhaps, until that one time when the sheer wonder of the “the Lord, the giver of life” lights up the interior space of your soul. You see that all the pulsing hearts, breathing lungs, and firing synapses in all the creatures of this planet and all the fiery gaseous planets of all the galaxies in the universe owe their very existence to the life-giving Holy Spirit. And the size of that thought is so immense that you have to hang on to the pew in front of you for a minute. That is the edification that the creeds offer now and then, if you pay attention to the words and what they mean.

Seventh, the creeds can comfort Christians. At times, the creeds may put broken believers back together again. Gordon MacDonald imagines that creeds are like the nails in his New Hampshire home. The clapboards work loose during the long, hard winters and need to be renailed each spring. “One of the great joys of repeating the Christian creed is that it gives an opportunity to reaffirm the central truths of God’s revelation,” MacDonald writes. “As we say ‘I believe,’ …we begin to hammer back the nails of our convictions and commitments.”7

Even that most dense and abstract creedal word of all, the famous Greek word homoousios, had a pastoral intent. This precise philosophical word, which refers to Christ’s full divine nature with the Father—“of one Being with the Father”—was also a model for the unity that ought to characterize the Christian. Thus, homoousios, the mysterious oneness between Father and Son, is the standard of mutuality and reciprocity within the Christian community as well. The ancient line in the Nicene Creed, “of one Being with the Father,” might serve as a pastoral reminder of the kind of unity that ought to characterize relationships in our churches, our marriages, our social structures, and our friendships.

If we recognize the creeds as fellow workers in the common task of serving God, we will be able to study them and puzzle through them, yet consider them to be trusted guides and teachers, sages in the faith. Once we have listened well, we will have the freedom and confidence to bring our questions to them.

Rainer Maria Rilke once advised a young poet, “I want to beg you, as much as I can, dear sir, to be patient towards all that is unsolved in your heart, and try to love the questions themselves.”8 Hasty conclusions about deep mysteries of the faith often short-circuit opportunities for growth. Perhaps the Orthodox priest was on to something: “Well, you just say it. With a little practice and effort, most can learn it by heart.”

This article appeared in Theology Matters, Vol. 16, No. 5 (Nov/Dec 2010).

Notes

  1. Kathleen Norris, Amazing Grace: A Vocabulary of Faith (New York: Riverhead Books, 1998), 64-65. See Ron Byar’s chapter on the creeds in A More Profound Alleluia: Theology and Worship in Harmony (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2005), for a treatment of this story and a discussion of the creeds in our culture. ↩
  2. I am indebted to Scott Hoezee’s helpful study guide Speaking as One: A Look at the Ecumenical Creeds (Grand Rapids: CRC Publications, 1997), 12-13. ↩
  3. See Joseph D. Small, “The Spirit and the Creed,” in Fire and Wind: The Holy Spirit in the Church Today, ed. J. Small (Louisville, KY: Geneva Press, 2002), 4-8. ↩
  4. The Treatise on the Apostolic Tradition of St. Hippolytus of Rome, Bishop and Martyr, ed. Gregory Dix and Henry Chadwick (London: Alban Press, 1991), 20.1-2, pp. 30-31. ↩
  5. Robert Kingdom, ed. Registers of the Consistory of Geneva in the Time of Calvin, vol. 1, 1542-1544 (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1996), 26.
  6. I learned this polemical function of the affirmations of the creed from John D. Witvliet, who develops a similar approach to the use of doxology and praise in this article “Isaiah in Christian Liturgy: Recovering Textual Contrasts and Correcting Theological Astigmatism,” Calvin Theological Journal 39, no.1 (April 2004): 135-56. ↩
  7. Gordon MacDonald, Ordering Your Private World (Nashville: Thomas Nelson, 1984), 168, quoted in Marianne Micks, Loving the Questions (Valley Forge, PA: Trinity Press International, 1993), 9. ↩
  8. Frances Young, The Making of the Creeds (Philadelphia: Trinity Press International, 1991), 19. ↩

Continue the issue

Continue Reading

More Articles

View All Articles
Reader-Supported

"Sustained by readers."

Theology Matters is sent in print to anyone who requests it, sustained primarily by readers like you. Tax-deductible.

Give a Gift