Barth, Bonhoeffer, Christian Life, Essay

The Courage to Stand, Part 1: Bonhoeffer’s Journey and Ours

Bonhoeffer was not always bold. In autumn 1933 he fled to London, weary and anxious, and Karl Barth answered with a sharp letter. Richard Burnett asks what that exchange teaches about finding courage to stand.

Listen to this essay
 

Read by an AI voice generated by ElevenLabs

Crowd of onlookers outside the burned Reichstag building in Berlin after the fire of 27 February 1933
Fire at the Reichstag Building, Berlin, February 1933. Press photograph by an unidentified photographer, distributed through a news agency. For details, see the catalogue comments for the image file in the Narodowe Archiwum Cyfrowe (National Digital Archives of Poland)., public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
In this essay

The story of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, the young Lutheran pastor who stood for the gospel of Jesus Christ, who resisted the Nazification of his church, who eventually decided to join a plot to assassinate Adolf Hitler, and who was hanged as a consequence of his involvement in this plot, his story is familiar to many.

Bonhoeffer’s life has inspired many because he bore faithful witness in one of the most severe periods of testing of Christians, especially Protestant Christians, in the twentieth century. Where would Protestants be on the world’s stage in the twentieth century without Bonhoeffer’s witness? He was a strong, resolute, courageous young theologian who confessed the faith and not only wrote a book about the cost of discipleship, but he paid the price for it with his life. Under enormous pressure, he stood bold and unbending. In the face of great temptation, he was unwavering, unyielding, firm, and unflinching in his commitment to lay down his life for the sheep.

Yet Bonhoeffer was not always so bold and unbending. Few biographers mention it, but there was a period when he was not so firm and unflinching, so strong, resolute, or unwavering. There was a time when he was quite weary, confused, and anxious.

I do not know if you have known times when you were quite weary, confused, or anxious, but I have. And I thought it might be helpful to think with you about this time in Bonhoeffer’s life, and to ask if there is anything we can learn from his journey about our own.

Bonhoeffer’s upbringing and education

Bonhoeffer grew up in a prominent, elite, highly educated family in Berlin, the sixth of eight children, the youngest of four sons. His father, Karl, was a world-renowned psychiatrist and neurologist on the faculty of the University of Berlin and Director of the famous university hospital Charite. Biographers claim he was ambivalent about religion, if not an agnostic. What is clear is that the Bonhoeffer family rarely went to church. Dietrich’s older siblings saw the church as a pathetic, mediocre institution that existed primarily to promote middle class values. So, when he announced at age fourteen that he was going to become a pastor, his older siblings teased him and told him that “the church to which he proposed to devote himself was a poor, feeble, boring, petty, bourgeois institution,” to which young Dietrich replied, “In that case I shall reform it.”1

He began his studies at the University of Tübingen in 1923 when a debate erupted in the pages of the most prestigious church journal, Die christliche Welt. It was between the most esteemed, influential, and internationally renowned scholars in Germany, Adolf von Harnack, Professor of Church History at the University of Berlin, and a young pastor from an obscure Swiss village who had written a commentary on the Epistle to the Romans, Karl Barth. A theological revolution led by Barth had emerged and was attracting younger pastors and theologians in Germany, including Dietrich Bonhoeffer. Professor von Harnack was trying to put a lid on it. His article was entitled, “Fifteen Questions to Those Among the Theologians Who Are Contemptuous of the Scientific Theology,” to which Barth immediately responded, “Fifteen Answers to Professor von Harnack.” Caught up in this revolution, Bonhoeffer returned to Berlin the next year to study under Harnack, who was a friend and colleague of his father. Despite this family connection, Dietrich’s classmates reported that he repeatedly challenged Professor Harnack in class, defending the theological revolution Barth had begun.

Bonhoeffer was a brilliant student of theology. At age twenty-one, he wrote a brilliant doctoral dissertation entitled, Sanctorum Communio. It is remarkable not only because of its content but because he defended it successfully under the most theologically liberal faculty in the world. His teachers, von Harnack, Karl Holl, and Reinhold Seeberg, were all renowned theological liberals. Despite their disagreements, Bonhoeffer respected them, and they respected him. He had earned their respect because (as ‘classical liberals’) they admired his scholarship. Indeed, they respected him so much that the following year, 1931, they approved him as a lecturer in Systematic Theology at the University of Berlin.

The German church struggle

By 1931, however, it was clear to most that the Weimar Republic, Germany’s first experiment in democracy, was failing and, with social, economic, and political pressures mounting, was on the verge of collapse. Fears, not unfounded, of a Bolshevik revolution loomed, terrifying most Germans, including most Christians, and leading many to vote for the National Socialist Party, which gained thirty-seven percent of the popular vote in 1932. Thus, after a long period of political gridlock, President Hindenburg appointed Adolf Hitler as chancellor. Hitler was sworn in on Jan. 30, 1933. Bonhoeffer and his family were distressed and openly expressed their concerns.2

On Feb. 27, the Reichstag, Germany’s main government building in Berlin, was set ablaze, allegedly, by a young Dutch Communist, Marinus Van der Lubbe. About the size of the Capitol Building in Washington D.C., the Reichstag was completely gutted by the fire, which sent the nation into panic. For Germany, it was a kind of 9/11 experience, only worse because it proved, according to the Nazis, how dangerous the Communists within the body politic were and how desperate the situation was.

A state of emergency was declared on Feb. 28 which was the first step toward suspending civil rights such as the right to privacy, freedom of speech, freedom of the press, freedom of assembly, etc. On March 23, a law for “Removing the Distress of People and Reich” was enacted which transferred legislative power from the Parliament to the Chancellery, giving Hitler unprecedented powers—powers to declare martial law and turn Germany essentially into a police state. On April 7, a law for “the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service” was passed that prohibited any non-Aryan from holding public office, including professors, teachers, and ministers in the German Evangelical (Evangelisch i.e., Protestant) Church.

Days later, Bonhoeffer delivered a lecture, “The Church and the Jewish Question,” in which he stated that the church is obliged “to aid the victims of state action,” even if they “do not belong to the Christian community.” If this fails, he said, the church must act “not just to bandage the victims under the wheel, but to jam a spoke in the wheel itself.”3

Bonhoeffer spent the next six months rallying the church, helping its leaders to understand what was happening and to recognize that they were facing a confessional crisis (a status confessionis), a time when the church must speak and act or else betray the gospel of Jesus Christ. But the German Evangelical Church was deeply divided and various groups in the Church had different ideas about what to do. There was: 1) a group of younger pastors known as the “Young Reformers,” who wanted to split and start a new “free church,” independent of the main body; 2) there was a “Young Church” group (Junge Kirche) who took a “‘tread softly’ and ‘take it easy’ attitude” toward what was happening4; 3) and then there were the so-called “German Christians,” a highly vocal minority, who stood in favor of a Nazified church, a church that was aligned with the values and reforms championed by the new Nazi government. Indeed, if there was ever a group convinced that they were on ‘the right side of history,’ it was they.5

It was in the middle of this boiling cauldron of ecclesial chaos that Bonhoeffer bore witness to Jesus Christ by teaching, preaching, counseling, exhorting, admonishing, debating, persuading, having meeting after meeting, one hard conversation after another, trying to convince his friends, his students, and his colleagues to go in one direction rather than another. It must have been exhausting. Yet he was there in the middle of what came soon to be known as the Kirchenkampf, the church struggle.

He was there when Karl Barth, then professor of Dogmatics at the University of Bonn, published a pamphlet on June 25, entitled, Theological Existence Today!, which awakened many in Germany and throughout the world to the crisis the German Church and the German people now faced. Bonhoeffer came to know Barth personally when he attended a seminar Barth taught at Bonn in 1931. Barth became his mentor. They corresponded. He became not only increasingly close but also helpful to Barth because Bonhoeffer was not only a bright young theologian, but he was also a Berliner who had his finger on the pulse of much that was going on inside both the Church and the State.

Bonhoeffer was also very helpful to Martin Niemöller, pastor of the Dahlem congregation in Berlin, in organizing the Pastor’s Emergency League. Niemöller was a decorated U-Boat Commander in the First World War whose patriotism could hardly be questioned. He sent out a four-point pledge to all the ministers in the Church, asking them whether they would still stand, according to their ordination vows, “bound solely to Holy Scripture and to the Confessions of the Reformation,” and would, on this basis, reject the so-called “Aryan Paragraph,” as a violation of their confessional stand. Seven thousand pastors responded that they would.

Throughout the spring and summer of 1933, Bonhoeffer was in the middle of it all—delivering lectures, preaching sermons, writing letters, drafting essays, and using his diplomatic and interpersonal skills to gather, inform, awaken, and motivate church leaders to speak and to act. And more and more, they looked to him for leadership.

Time to go into the wilderness

But then, abruptly, in mid-October, when so much was still up in the air, when so many decisions had yet to be made, when most pastors still had no idea what a confessing church was, let alone what it would cost to become one—amid all this chaos and confusion—Bonhoeffer simply walked away. He left Germany to serve two small congregations of German refugees in London, England. Many wondered why.

On Oct. 24, a week after arriving in London, he wrote to Barth to explain. He said that he “wanted to write six weeks ago” and “Why I did not write to you then is now almost incomprehensible to me. … I knew that you were busy with a thousand other things …” He told Barth that he knew he should have asked him first, but he said: “I knew that I would have to do what you told me and I wanted to remain free; so I simply withdrew myself.” He asked Barth “to forgive [him].” And then he explained: “I simply did not any longer feel up to the questions and demands which came to me. … I was afraid I would go wrong out of obstinacy—and I saw no reason why I should see these things more correctly, better than so many able and good pastors, to whom I looked up—and so I thought that it was probably time to go into the wilderness for a while and simply do pastoral work, with as little demands as possible. The danger of provoking a reaction at the present moment seemed to me greater than that of going off for some quietness. So off I went.”6

Bonhoeffer talked about having always wanted to be a pastor, about his pastoral duties, and about his desire to do ecumenical work, not least for the sake of the German Church. But he felt torn. He said, “[I] receive news almost daily from Berlin about the state of affairs. That almost tears one apart inside. And now you will soon be in Berlin and I cannot be there. It also occurs to me that I have let you down personally by my going away. Perhaps you will not understand that.” He concluded: “I think of you and your work very often, and where we would be without it. Would you please let me have your frank opinion on all this? I would be ready, and thankful, I think, even for a sharp word.”7

Hurry back to your post in Berlin!

If Bonhoeffer was asking for some tough love, he got it. Few biographies of Bonhoeffer mention his exchange with Barth at this time, and none give it the attention it deserves. But it had a profound influence on Bonhoeffer, which I will seek to demonstrate. It has certainly given me a lot to think about over the years, and I wonder if it has anything to say to you. It is deeply personal. It yields deep insight into how theology mattered to these men at one of the most stressful periods in their lives. And even if you have never read one page of Barth or Bonhoeffer, I think you will understand much that is at issue here.

Bonhoeffer said he wanted to hear from Barth, even if it is “a sharp word.” On Nov. 20, Barth wrote to him:

You can infer from the way in which I address you that I do not consider your retreat to England as anything but a necessary personal interlude. Once you had this matter on your mind, you were quite right not to seek my wise counsel first. I would have advised you against it entirely, and probably by bringing up my heaviest guns. And now, as you mention it to me after the fact, I can honestly not tell you anything but ‘Hurry back to your post in Berlin!’

What is all this about ‘getting distance,’ ‘the quietness of pastoral work,’ etc., at a moment when you are needed just now in Germany? You, who know as well as I do that the opposition in Berlin and the opposition of the church in Germany as a whole stands inwardly on such weak feet! That every honest man should be fully absorbed in making our opposition sharp and clear and firm! That now perhaps everything is falling apart not because of the supposedly great power and cunning of the German Christians, but because of the pig-headedness, stupidity, and desperate shallowness of, of all people, the anti-German Christians!8

In other words, it was not that the Nazified German Christians were so strong or clever. It was that the other groups were so weak, dull, and theologically superficial. Bonhoeffer had expressed a similar frustration working with these groups. And now he risked losing friends.

Losing and finding friends

He told Barth: “I felt that I was incomprehensibly in radical opposition to all my friends, that my views of matters were taking me more and more into isolation, although I was and remained in the closest personal relationship with these men—and all that made me anxious, made me uncertain.”9 Barth said bluntly what Bonhoeffer tried to say politely. Working with such groups was indeed frustrating. It was ‘worse than herding cats,’ which is why the unity granted six months later at Barmen was such a “miracle.”10

Neither man knew such a miracle would come, but that did not absolve them from doing their duty now, which is why Barth told Bonhoeffer he could not just run away:

One can now under no circumstances play Elijah under the juniper tree or Jonah under the plant, but must shoot with all barrels! What use is the praise you lavish on me—from the other side of the channel?! What use was the message which your student gave me when I was busy having it out with the brilliant ‘council of brethren’ of the Emergency League instead of your being there and supporting me against these brethren?11

Barth was sarcastic in referring to “the brilliant ‘council of brethren’ of the Emergency League.” He did not think them brilliant. Their leader was Martin Niemöller, the former U-Boat commander, whom Barth was just getting to know. Bold, decisive, Niemöller was in some ways ‘a piece of work.’ He was used to giving orders, not taking them. Even his colleagues in ministry said that sometimes from “the tone of the voice of the former submarine commander at meetings in his parish house, they could have sworn they were sitting in the officers’ mess.”12

But what Niemöller lacked in theological knowledge or professional tact or etiquette he made up for in courage. In 1952, Barth said their relationship had gone more or less like this: “Martin, it amazes me that despite drawing upon so little theology, you still almost always come out at the right place,” to which Niemöller replied: “Karl, it amazes me that despite drawing upon so much systematic theology, you still almost always come out at the right place.”13 They were so different and had such different gifts and personalities. But having stood together for the faith, they could laugh about it in 1952 because they did not let such differences stand in their way in 1933. They both knew the stakes were simply too high, which is what Barth was trying to communicate to Bonhoeffer:

Look, I have now been to Berlin twice in recent weeks and I think that I know rather well what is going on there. I have also tried my best to grab the helm and steer in a different direction, and I have also had some degree of success; but if things are to turn out well, I will need a quite, quite different kind of success, and so I went away from the place very depressed, particularly the second time. Why weren’t you there to pull on the sail with me, the sail that I could hardly raise by myself? Why aren’t you always there, where now so much could depend on there being a few courageous people on the watch at every occasion, great or small, and trying to save what there is to be saved? Why, why?14

And the German church?

Barth turns the screws in tight here. Yet he, too, was feeling enormous pressure as leader of the emerging Confessing Church; and it is understandable why he wanted Bonhoeffer at his side in these meetings. Bonhoeffer was a highly respected young theologian in Berlin. He had paid his dues and earned the right to be heard in the academy and, increasingly, in the church. At the University of Berlin, he was the only student asked to speak at Professor von Harnack’s memorial service in 1930.15 He was also a very popular lecturer. Three hundred students attended his lectures on Creation and Fall in the winter semester of 1932–33. Bonhoeffer was such a credible, articulate, effective leader from such a prominent, well-connected family in Berlin, it is easy to understand why Barth wanted him near. He tells Bonhoeffer that with his “splendid theological arsenal,” especially compared to others in the fight, he ought to be “a little ashamed” not to be using it.16 Barth continues:

Look, I gladly assume, as I have already said, that this retreat was personally necessary for you! But I must be permitted to add, ‘What does even “personally necessary” mean at the present moment?!’ I think that I can see from your letter that you, like all of us—yes, like all of us!—are suffering under the quite enormous difficulty of taking ‘certain steps’ in the present chaos. But should it not dawn on you that that is no reason for withdrawing from this chaos, that we are rather required in and with our uncertainty, even if we should stumble or fail ten times or a hundred times, to do our bit, whether we then help our cause or damage it? I will just not allow you to put such a private tragedy on the stage in view of what is at stake for the German church today, as though there were not time afterwards, when if God will we have got a little way out of this mess again, for the study of the different complexes and inhibitions from which you suffer, as indeed others also must. No, to all the reasons or excuses which you might perhaps still be able to put in front of me, I will give only one answer: ‘and the German church?’ ‘And the German church?’—until you are back again in Berlin to attend faithfully and bravely to the machine-gun which you have left behind there.17

What does personally necessary mean?

Barth rejects all of Bonhoeffer’s excuses and “special considerations.”18 He grants that his “retreat was personally necessary,” but he refuses to let him hide behind personal necessity, asking, “What does even ‘personally necessary’ mean at the present moment?” Barth refuses to let Bonhoeffer set personal considerations up as an obstacle to discipleship. And if you have read The Cost of Discipleship, you will remember that Bonhoeffer examines in detail the various ‘personal’ excuses various would-be disciples give in Luke 9:57–62.

Barth and Bonhoeffer were challenging a basic premise of modernity, namely, the idea that we are all first free, independent, self-determining, self-actualizing agents, individuals, or persons before we belong to God or before we are called by God—as if we were ‘persons’ apart from our call, or that we have an identity apart from our calling as disciples. By contrast, Barth, and later Bonhoeffer, argued that it is only in fulfilling God’s calling on our lives that we truly become persons or individuals, or that we have an identity. In The Cost of Discipleship, Bonhoeffer devotes an entire chapter to this theme, entitled, “Discipleship and the Individual.”19

One simply cannot become weary just now

Barth does not sugar-coat the task or minimize the cost of the battle. Nor does he try to lure Bonhoeffer back by any prospect of victory. Rather, he says:

I cannot really give you the prospect of taking part in a triumph, when I ask you to return to Germany. Here everything is as difficult and unpleasant as you can imagine, and as far as one engages in tactical or historical-philosophical thought even a little bit, one can realize every moment that—the sea rages and will have its victims—in spite of all efforts, the German church is still lost.20

Is this not amazing? Barth recognized as early as November 1933 that “in spite of all efforts, the German church is still lost,” that the situation was hopeless, impossible, a lost cause, humanly speaking. Yet he not only continued to fight, to bear witness, to stand faithful, to do his duty. He encouraged and, indeed, he compelled others to do the same. Yet notice that Barth also admits his own struggle against weariness. Referring to some of his recent writings as an example, he says:

You will see … how much trouble I myself have had in not becoming weary. But, you see, one simply cannot become weary just now. Still less may one go to England! What in all the world should and would you want to do over there? Be glad that I do not have you here in person, for I would confront you even more intensely in quite a different way, with the demand that you must now let go of all these intellectual flourishes and special considerations, however interesting they may be, and think of only one thing, that you are a German, that the house of your church is on fire, that you know enough and can say what you know well enough to be able to help, and that you must really return to your post by the next ship. Well, shall we say the ship after next? But I cannot tell you emphatically and urgently enough that you belong to Berlin and not to London.21

The house of your church is on fire

Barth saved his most importunate plea for last: “think of only one thing, that you are a German, that the house of your church is on fire, that you know enough and can say what you know well enough to be able to help …”

There is a lot of talk today about Christian nationalism. Barth and Bonhoeffer were not nationalists in the sense that they absolutized or divinized nationhood, entertained romantic forms of nationalism, or thought they owed unconditional allegiance to their respective nations.22 On the contrary, both delineated the limits of state power, and stated conditions when it could be actively resisted. Both also insisted that the church has a divine responsibility to the state and a divine obligation to acknowledge its gratitude for the state as the Barmen Declaration’s Fifth Article makes clear. Moreover, both insisted that Christians have civic duties, responsibilities to one’s fellow citizens, and there is a proper form of patriotism and gratitude for and responsibility to one’s country.23

I was greatly mistaken

Dietrich Bonhoeffer had asked for a “sharp word” from Karl Barth, and he got one. Yet Barth had deep affection for him, and this was not the end of their relationship but only the beginning.24 It was also only the beginning of Bonhoeffer’s journey in finding the courage to stand. Barth’s letter no doubt made a deep impression on him, and it is hard to imagine it did not shake him. Indeed, he was so “impressed” that he sent Barth’s letter to his father, the world-renowned psychiatrist, perhaps for analysis. And the world-renowned psychiatrist observed, “It is striking testimony to a fiery spirit.”25

Yet that is not all he said. Do you remember that I said biographers claim Bonhoeffer’s father was ambivalent toward religion, if not an “agnostic”?26 Perhaps he was. Whether he remained so, I am not sure anyone knows. But here is what the world-renowned psychiatrist wrote to his son, Dietrich, a year or so later, on Jan 14, 1935:

When you made up your mind to study theology, I sometimes could not help thinking that it would be a pity for you to have the quiet, uneventful life of a minister, such as I knew my Swabian uncles had … . As far as it being uneventful is concerned, I was greatly mistaken. I had no conception, with my scientific background, that nowadays there could be such a crisis in the ecclesiastical sphere too.27

Karl Bonhoeffer was not the only scientist or agnostic to wake up to a deeper crisis facing Germany as a consequence of the witness of his son and the Confessing Church. There were many scientists, agnostics, and cultured despisers of religion who were awakened as a consequence of the witness of the Confessing Church in the 1930s.28 It is this witness that I would like to talk with you more about next time.

This address was delivered on March 4, 2026, at the fifth Theology Matters’ conference at Providence Presbyterian Church, Hilton Head Island, South Carolina.

Notes

  1. See Eberhard Bethge, Dietrich Bonhoeffer: Man of Vision—Man of Courage (New York, 1970), 22.
  2. The next day, Feb.1, Bonhoeffer delivered a radio talk on “The Leader and the Individual in the Younger Generation,” in which he said that a leader could become “an idol for the masses” and that “If [the Leader] does not continually tell his followers quite clearly of the limited nature of his task and of their own responsibility … then the image of the Leader will pass over into the image of the misleader.” Cited in Renate Wind, Dietrich Bonhoeffer: A Spoke in the Wheel (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1992), 66f. This last part of his radio talk, however, was cut short “allegedly because it ran over time.” Furious, Bonhoeffer had his lecture published in a newspaper.
  3. Dietrich Bonhoeffer, “The Church and the Jewish Question” in Berlin: 1932–1933: Dietrich Bonhoeffer Works, vol. 12, ed. Larry Rasmussen, trans. Isabel Best, David Higgins, Douglas W. Scott (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2009), 361–374.
  4. “I have also just now been reading the Junge Kirche on the matter, glad of any information, but really quite distressed by the ‘tread softly’ and ‘take it easy’ attitude which holds the field. Can’t anyone see that the German Christians will just laugh at opponents who speak and behave like this? God help the German church if the opposition from within the church, which is so badly needed just now, cannot get hold of other viewpoints and other principles and, above all a different language, instead of this brave and yet so fearful muddle which is all one can see at the moment.” Letter from Barth to Bonhoeffer, Sept. 11, 1933, Gesammelte Schriften II (München: Christian Kaiser, 1965), 129 (hereafter GS II); ET No Rusty Swords, trans. John Bowden (New York: Harper & Row, 1965, 233.
  5. See Doris L. Bergen, Twisted Cross: The German Christian Movement in the Third Reich (Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press, 1996).
  6. Bonhoeffer to Barth, Oct. 24, 1933, GS II, 132; ET 235–236.
  7. Bonhoeffer to Barth, Oct. 24, 1933, GS II, 133–134; ET 236–237.
  8. Barth to Bonhoeffer, Nov. 11, 1933, GS II, 134; ET 237–238.
  9. Bonhoeffer to Barth, Oct. 24, 1933, GS II, 132; ET 235.
  10. Karl Barth, Church Dogmatics, eds. G. W. Bromiley and T. F. Torrance (Edinburgh: T & T Clark, 1936-62), II/1:176.
  11. Barth to Bonhoeffer, Nov. 11, 1933, GS II, 134–135; ET 238.
  12. Ferdinand Schlingensiepan, Dietrich Bonhoeffer 1906–1945: Martyr, Thinker, Man of Resistance, trans. Isabel Best (London: T&T Clark International, 2010), 128.
  13. See Bekennende Kirche. Martin Niemöller zum 60. Geburtstag (Festschrift) eds. Joachim Beckmann and Herbert Mochalski (München: Christian Kaiser Verlag, 1952), 9.
  14. Barth to Bonhoeffer, Nov. 11, 1933, GS II, 135; ET 238.
  15. Bethge, Dietrich Bonhoeffer: A Life in Pictures, 72.
  16. “With your splendid theological arsenal and your upright German stature, should you not perhaps be almost a little ashamed at a man like Heinrich Vogel, who, wizened and worked up as he is, is just always there, waving his arms like a windmill and shouting ‘Confession! Confession!’ in his own way—in strength or in weakness, that doesn’t matter so much —actually giving his testimony?” Barth to Bonhoeffer, Nov. 11, 1933, GS II, 136; ET 239. Barth’s admiration of Vogel grew. Two years later he dedicated his lectures on the Apostles’ Creed, Credo, to Vogel, Niemöller, Hans Asmussen, Hermann Hesse, Karl Immer and “all who stood, stand, and will stand.”
  17. Barth to Bonhoeffer, Nov. 11, 1933, GS II, 135–136; ET 238–239
  18. “Don’t you see yet that an age of completely undialectical theology has dawned, in which it just won’t do to keep oneself in reserve with a ‘Perhaps—but again, perhaps not!’? Don’t you see that any Bible verse you like formally cries out to us that we, lost and condemned sinners, should now simply believe, believe, believe?!” Barth to Bonhoeffer, Nov. 11, 1933, GS II, 136; ET 239.
  19. For more on this topic, see William H. Willimon, “Why a Pastor Should Not Be a Person,” Theology Today 50:4. (Jan. 1994), 580–585. See Bonhoeffer’s, Discipleship, trans. Barbara Green and Reinhard Krauss (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2001), 92–99, esp. the reference to Karl Barth’s Römerbrief in 92N2. See also Barth, Church Dogmatics III/2:222–285 (¶45).
  20. Barth to Bonhoeffer, Nov. 11, 1933, GS II, 136; ET 239.
  21. Barth to Bonhoeffer, Nov. 11, 1933, GS II, 136–137; ET 239–240.
  22. Carys Moseley, Nations and Nationalism in the Theology of Karl Barth (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2013).
  23. See Dietrich Bonhoeffer, True Patriotism. Letters, Lectures and Notes 1939–45 from the Collected Works of Dietrich Bonhoeffer, vol, 3, ed. Edwin H. Robertson and John Bowden.

    “[I]f ‘patriotism’ means an awareness and love for the reality of one’s national heritage, then on this count alone Bonhoeffer would earn the title of ‘true patriot’” Keith Clements, A Patriotism for Today: Love of Country in Dialogue with the Witness of Dietrich Bonhoeffer (London: Collins, 1986), 87.
  24. For more insight into their relationship, see Andreas Pangritz, Karl Barth in the Theology of Dietrich Bonhoeffer (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000).
  25. Eberhard Bethge, Dietrich Bonhoeffer: Eine Biographie (München: Christian Kaiser Verlag, 1967), 380; ET Dietrich Bonhoeffer: A Biography, ed. Victoria Barnett (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2000), 326.
  26. Owing to Karl Bonhoeffer’s “austerity,” Renate Wind speculates: “It is hard here to tell how much imagination and emotion Dietrich learned to suppress in himself as an adolescent,” Wind, Spoke in the Wheel, 23. However, this is not how Karl Bonhoeffer’s children describe his influence.
  27. Eberhard Bethge, Costly Grace, trans. Rosaleen Ockenden (New York: Harper & Row, 1979), 26.
  28. Bonhoeffer discusses this phenomenon in Spiritual Care, trans. Jay C. Rochelle (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1985), 48f.

Continue the issue

Continue Reading

More Articles

View All Articles
Reader-Supported

"Sustained by readers."

Theology Matters is sent in print to anyone who requests it, sustained primarily by readers like you. Tax-deductible.

Give a Gift